Inventory valuation and stock counting for small businesses in India
In Indian accounts, closing stock is valued at the lower of cost and net realisable value (NRV). Cost is worked out by the first-in, first-out (FIFO) or weighted average formula for interchangeable goods, and by specific identification for items that are unique or set aside for a particular project. Last-in, first-out (LIFO) is not one of the permitted formulas. Counting the stock regularly keeps the books honest, because the valuation is only as good as the quantities behind it.
At a glance
- Accounting Standard (AS) 2 (revised 2016) applies to companies under the Companies (Accounting Standards) Rules, 2021, and ICAI made it mandatory for entities other than companies for periods starting on or after 1 April 2017. Ind AS 2 is the equivalent for companies that follow Ind AS.
- The rule in both is the lower of cost and NRV, applied item by item in most cases.
- The permitted cost formulas are FIFO and weighted average, plus specific identification where goods are not ordinarily interchangeable. Both standards name only these.
- Tax that you can claim back (such as GST input tax credit) is not part of cost. Selling and distribution costs, abnormal wastage and most administrative overheads are also left out.
- Management should physically verify all material items at least once a year, and more often in suitable cases. Continuous (cycle) counting is an accepted method.
- Under GST, credit on goods that are lost, stolen, destroyed or written off is not allowed.
Which standard applies, and the basic rule
AS 2 defines inventories as assets held for sale in the ordinary course of business, in the process of production for such sale, or in the form of materials or supplies to be consumed in production or in providing services. Spare parts and standby equipment that qualify as property, plant and equipment are outside it.
Ind AS 2 contains the same core rule: inventories are measured at the lower of cost and NRV. Which standard binds you depends on your entity. Listed and larger companies follow Ind AS; other companies follow AS under the 2021 Rules; non-company businesses follow ICAI's AS. Ask your chartered accountant which applies. Income tax has its own rules on stock valuation, which this article does not cover.
NRV is the estimated selling price in the ordinary course of business, less the estimated cost of completion and the estimated costs needed to make the sale.
What goes into cost
Cost covers the cost of purchase, the cost of conversion and other costs of bringing the goods to their present location and condition.
| Included | Excluded and expensed |
|---|---|
| Purchase price, import duties and taxes that cannot be claimed back, freight inwards, other direct acquisition costs | Taxes you can recover from the tax authorities |
| Direct labour for goods you make | Abnormal wastage of materials, labour or other production costs |
| Fixed and variable production overheads, allocated systematically | Storage costs, unless needed before a further production stage |
| Other costs only to the extent they bring goods to their present location and condition | Administrative overheads that do not bring goods to their location and condition |
| Less: trade discounts and rebates | Selling and distribution costs |
Fixed production overheads are allocated on the normal capacity of the plant. In a slow month, the fixed overhead per unit is not increased; the unallocated amount is an expense of that period. Interest and other borrowing costs are usually not part of the cost of inventories.
FIFO and weighted average compared
FIFO assumes the goods bought or made first are sold first, so the stock left at the end is the most recent purchases. Under the weighted average formula, the cost per unit comes from the average of the cost of opening stock and purchases, calculated either for the period or after each receipt. Either formula must give the fairest possible approximation to cost, and the same one should be used for goods of similar nature and use.
Illustration. A distributor starts October with 100 units at ₹50. It buys 200 units at ₹56 on 5 October and 100 units at ₹62 on 15 October, and sells 250 units on 20 October. Total cost is ₹5,000 + ₹11,200 + ₹6,200 = ₹22,400 for 400 units. Closing stock is 150 units.
| FIFO | Weighted average (periodic) | |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of the 250 units sold | 100 × ₹50 + 150 × ₹56 = ₹13,400 | 250 × ₹56 = ₹14,000 |
| Closing stock of 150 units | 50 × ₹56 + 100 × ₹62 = ₹9,000 | 150 × ₹56 = ₹8,400 |
| Total | ₹22,400 | ₹22,400 |
The weighted average cost is ₹22,400 ÷ 400 = ₹56 per unit. When prices rise, FIFO shows a higher closing stock (₹9,000 against ₹8,400) and therefore a profit higher by ₹600 for the period. Pick the formula that suits how goods really flow, apply it consistently and disclose it in the accounting policy.
NRV, damaged and obsolete stock
Stock may not be recoverable at cost if it is damaged, wholly or partly obsolete, or if selling prices have fallen or completion and selling costs have risen. The standard writes it down to NRV, usually item by item. Writing down a whole class, such as all finished goods, is not appropriate, and NRV is assessed again at each balance sheet date.
Illustration. 40 units are in stock at a cost of ₹56 each (₹2,240). Because of damage they can be sold at ₹60 each after repairs costing ₹8 and selling costs of ₹4 per unit. NRV is ₹60 − ₹8 − ₹4 = ₹48 per unit, or ₹1,920 for the 40 units. The write-down is ₹2,240 − ₹1,920 = ₹320, charged as an expense, and the stock is carried at ₹1,920.
Two further points apply. Raw materials are not written down below cost if the finished goods they go into are expected to sell at or above cost. Where a firm sales contract exists, NRV for those quantities uses the contract price. Under Ind AS 2, a write-down that is later reversed because NRV has risen is recognised as a reduction in the inventory expense. Keep an ageing report so slow-moving and obsolete lines are reviewed before year end.
Counting stock and handling shortages
ICAI describes two methods. In periodic counting, all stock is counted at one date, usually near year end. In continuous counting (often called cycle counting), different items are counted at different times through the year, which works best with a perpetual stock record. The plan should still cover each material item at least once a year.
Sound count practice, drawn from ICAI's audit standard on inventory, includes:
- Count sheets or tags that are numbered, with used and unused ones accounted for.
- Counts and recounts of items that differ, and identification of slow-moving, obsolete or damaged items.
- Separate treatment of stock that belongs to someone else, such as goods on consignment.
- Control of goods received or dispatched around the count date, so the cut-off is clean.
When the count differs from the book, find out why before posting an adjustment: unrecorded issues, wrong units, goods in transit or theft. ICAI notes that gaps between a perpetual record and the physical stock can show that controls over stock movements are not working. Post the net shortage as a loss in the period it is found, and recount before writing off large amounts. For companies, the auditor reports under the Companies (Auditor's Report) Order, 2020 whether verification was done at reasonable intervals and whether discrepancies of 10% or more in aggregate for any class of inventory were properly dealt with in the books.
For example, if the books show 150 units at ₹56 and the count finds 146, the shortage is 4 units, or ₹224 at that cost.
GST points on stock
- Section 17(5)(h) of the CGST Act blocks input tax credit on goods lost, stolen, destroyed, written off or disposed of by way of gift or free samples. If such goods were bought with credit, the credit attributable to them is generally reversed.
- Whether a mere accounting write-down to NRV, while the goods are still saleable, triggers a reversal is argued in commentary and rulings. Treat physical loss, destruction, expiry and disposal as the clear triggers, and take advice on write-downs.
- Section 35(1) requires every registered person to keep a true and correct account of stock of goods, among other records.
- Because recoverable GST is excluded from cost, a stock valuation that includes it overstates inventory.
Common mistakes
- Valuing the whole stock at selling price instead of the lower of cost and NRV.
- Including recoverable GST, freight outwards or selling commission in cost.
- Using LIFO, or switching formulas between years to move profit.
- Adding unabsorbed factory overhead in a slow month into stock.
- Posting a count difference without investigating it or recounting.
- Leaving damaged, expired or slow-moving items at full cost.
Checklist
- Record which standard and which cost formula your accounts follow.
- Keep purchase invoices, freight bills and production records to support cost.
- Exclude recoverable GST, selling costs and abnormal wastage from cost.
- Run an ageing report on stock at least once a year.
- Compare cost with NRV item by item and write down where needed.
- Plan counts: a full count at year end or a cycle count covering every material item.
- Use numbered count sheets and a clean cut-off for receipts and dispatches.
- Investigate and document every count difference before adjusting the books.
- Reverse GST credit on goods lost, stolen or destroyed, as advised.
- Review the stock note with your chartered accountant before the audit.
Sources
- ICAI Accounting Standard 2 (revised 2016), Valuation of Inventories : definition, lower of cost and NRV, cost, exclusions, cost formulas, NRV, applicability note.
- ICAI Ind AS 2, Inventories : measurement, same cost formula for similar use, expense recognition and reversal.
- ICAI Expert Advisory Committee opinion on AS 2 : FIFO or weighted average, specific identification for non-interchangeable items.
- ICAI Guidance Note on CARO 2020 : physical verification, periodic and continuous methods, 10% discrepancy reporting.
- ICAI Standard on Auditing 501 : count instructions, cut-off, obsolete items, perpetual records.
- CBIC text of section 17 of the CGST Act : clause (h) of sub-section (5).
- CBIC consolidated CGST Act (as on 1 January 2022) : section 35(1) on stock accounts.
This is general information, not tax or legal advice; confirm your own case with a chartered accountant.