Fault-to-fix: control and audit worksheet
This worksheet lets a reviewer test whether faults in your machines, delivered products or services are really handled from first report to proven fix. An owner, quality head or outside reviewer uses it to pick a few closed faults and trace each one back through the records, looking for faults that were closed without being fixed.
When to use it
Use it once a month or quarter on a small sample, and after a repeat breakdown, a customer complaint about the same defect twice, or a repair that was charged but did not hold. It is also useful when the person who looks after maintenance or complaints changes. The aim is not to catch the technician out. It is to learn whether the routine you believe you have is the routine that actually runs, and where it quietly breaks.
The template
Pick at least five closed faults, including one that came back after closure. Use one worksheet per review.
| Ref | Control | How to test | Evidence to check | Tester | Result and note | Corrective action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F1 | Every fault has a log entry with date, place and reporter | Trace the sampled fault to the first report message or call | Fault log, message or call note | Reviewer | ||
| F2 | Severity was set and the response time matched it | Compare report time to first action time | Fault log, technician note | Reviewer | ||
| F3 | Cause was recorded in words, not just "fixed" | Read the cause field for each sampled fault | Job card, cause note | Reviewer | ||
| F4 | Parts or spares used match the stock record | Match parts on the job card to stock issued | Job card, stock issue slip | Reviewer | ||
| F5 | Someone other than the fixer confirmed the fix | Find the name and date of the person who checked | Verification note, photo or test reading | Reviewer | ||
| F6 | Customer or user was told the outcome | Look for the closing message | Message or call record | Reviewer | ||
| F7 | Repeat faults were linked and given a root cause review | Search the log for the same asset or defect within the review period | Fault log, review note | Reviewer | ||
| F8 | Cost of repair, including rework or credit, was booked | Compare job card cost to the expense or credit note | Job card, bill, credit note | Reviewer |
How to fill it
- Ref: keep the numbers fixed between reviews so results can be compared.
- How to test: write the fault numbers you sampled so another person can repeat the test.
- Evidence to check: record the document name and date, not just "seen".
- Tester: the person who ran the test, who must not be the person who closed the sampled faults.
- Result and note: write Pass or Fail with one line on what you saw.
- Corrective action: name the owner and a date, and say if the fault must be reopened.
- Sample choice: do not let the person being reviewed pick the faults. Draw them from the log yourself, and include at least one from each shift or branch, so the result reflects normal working and not the best days.
Example row
| Ref | Control | How to test | Evidence to check | Tester | Result and note | Corrective action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| F5 | Someone other than the fixer confirmed the fix | Fault 0412, packing machine sealing failure, closed 9 Oct | Verification note | Anita | Fail. Closed by the technician himself, no test run recorded. Machine failed again on 16 Oct, ₹6,200 of wasted film | Production head to rerun the test and sign by 3 Nov; make the verifier a different person |
Review and sign-off
- The reviewer signs and dates the worksheet and gives it to the owner.
- Run it every quarter, and monthly if more than one fault in five reopens.
- Escalate immediately to the owner if a fault touching safety or a customer's delivered goods was closed without proof, or if the same fault appears three times.
Keeping it up to date
- Add a row for any new control you introduce, such as a photo requirement, and retire rows only with the owner's sign-off.
- Keep the filled worksheets together so trends show over several reviews.
- Keep records for the period your CA or the law requires, and keep fault proofs for the warranty period you promise.